Dec. 30th, 2024 08:48 pm
2025 Schedule & Announcements
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Goreswap will run in 2025! The tentative schedule is:
Nominations: Jan 8-15
Sign ups: Open by Jan 17-24
Assignments out by: Jan 26
Assignments due: Mar 9
Work reveals: Mar 21
Creator reveals: Mar 28
In addition I have some announcements regarding the rules. These are not changes in the rules per se, but clarifications about questions I've received in the past, and some changes in enforcement:
1. Regarding RPF, and OW and fictional characters related to RPF works: real people famous for participation in the Nazi regime remain banned, as are fictionalized versions of real Nazis, as are Nazi OW nominations. Fictional Nazis may be banned at my discretion if I feel they are a violation of the above in spirit. HYDRA characters from the MCU are generally fine. Most living or recently living people primarily famous for committing atrocities are also banned, as are OW expies. In particular, Vladimir Putin is banned, as is any OW nomination I believe is meant to circumvent this rule. (The real serial killers rule remains as before, and has not generally required clarification.)
This rule is primarily enforced at the nomination stage due to the logistics of exchange matching, but I reserve the right to remove works circumventing the rule and ban their creators without recourse. (Please note that I am referring to cases which are, in my judgment, clearly meant to circumvent the rule. I am not going to ban you for a fic where Steve Rogers shoots Hitler.)
2. Regarding DNWs, transgender characters, and sexual orientation and gender identity: You are generally permitted to DNW altering canon characters' backstories, stories focusing or giving detail to certain topics, and particular sex acts, but not permitted to DNW minorities' existence within a story. You may DNW writing specific canon characters, or canon characters generally, as transgender if they are not already transgender in canon. You may DNW coming out scenes, introspection on gender identity or sexual orientation, explicit discussion of sexual orientation, anachronistic identity labels, conversations about gender identity, and similar. You may not DNW transgender characters or OCs in general. You may not DNW gay/bi/pan/etc characters. I am aware that many people DNW something in this spectrum because they do not want to read transgender characters engaging in specific sexual acts, due to dysphoria or otherwise, and I recommend that if this is the case, you DNW the act (e.g., "DNW: transgender characters engaged in PIV," "DNW: transmasculine characters bottoming for PIV," etc.)
I will not be giving participants in violation of this rule the option to leave the DNW up without enforcement; participants will be given the choice to edit their sign ups or have them removed from the exchange.
DNWs of "non-canon gender/sexuality headcanons" or "gender/sexuality headcanons" will conflict with many requests (for example, they would conflict with requesting a character in a same sex relationship if that character doesn't explicitly experience same sex attraction in canon) and will only apply to canon characters. As what constitutes a "headcanon" in the context of narrative fanfic (vs. fan discussion or meta) is ambiguous, I recommend you use something else more specific. If you don't want the characters to discuss their sexual orientations or gender identities explicitly, DNW that.
3. Regarding DNWs on the subject of characters' ethnic backgrounds: Similarly to above, you may DNW racebending or changing a character's ethnic background, race, or skin tone/physical description, but you may not DNW people of a given ethnicity or race in a story. Some characters, particularly existing within franchises, may have multiple backstories which give different ethnic backgrounds or appearances. It's fine to DNW a specific version's backstory; it is not fine to do so with offensive language. As above, if you violate this rule, I will require you to edit your sign up or have it removed from the exchange.
4. While I generally give people something of the benefit of the doubt, if I have evidence to believe you are likely to behave unreasonably, for example, your recent public behavior in other exchanges, I may ban you on this basis on my sole discretion. (If you're worrying this is about you, and you have not recently done something which would violate point one on this list, it probably isn't.)
Nominations: Jan 8-15
Sign ups: Open by Jan 17-24
Assignments out by: Jan 26
Assignments due: Mar 9
Work reveals: Mar 21
Creator reveals: Mar 28
In addition I have some announcements regarding the rules. These are not changes in the rules per se, but clarifications about questions I've received in the past, and some changes in enforcement:
1. Regarding RPF, and OW and fictional characters related to RPF works: real people famous for participation in the Nazi regime remain banned, as are fictionalized versions of real Nazis, as are Nazi OW nominations. Fictional Nazis may be banned at my discretion if I feel they are a violation of the above in spirit. HYDRA characters from the MCU are generally fine. Most living or recently living people primarily famous for committing atrocities are also banned, as are OW expies. In particular, Vladimir Putin is banned, as is any OW nomination I believe is meant to circumvent this rule. (The real serial killers rule remains as before, and has not generally required clarification.)
This rule is primarily enforced at the nomination stage due to the logistics of exchange matching, but I reserve the right to remove works circumventing the rule and ban their creators without recourse. (Please note that I am referring to cases which are, in my judgment, clearly meant to circumvent the rule. I am not going to ban you for a fic where Steve Rogers shoots Hitler.)
2. Regarding DNWs, transgender characters, and sexual orientation and gender identity: You are generally permitted to DNW altering canon characters' backstories, stories focusing or giving detail to certain topics, and particular sex acts, but not permitted to DNW minorities' existence within a story. You may DNW writing specific canon characters, or canon characters generally, as transgender if they are not already transgender in canon. You may DNW coming out scenes, introspection on gender identity or sexual orientation, explicit discussion of sexual orientation, anachronistic identity labels, conversations about gender identity, and similar. You may not DNW transgender characters or OCs in general. You may not DNW gay/bi/pan/etc characters. I am aware that many people DNW something in this spectrum because they do not want to read transgender characters engaging in specific sexual acts, due to dysphoria or otherwise, and I recommend that if this is the case, you DNW the act (e.g., "DNW: transgender characters engaged in PIV," "DNW: transmasculine characters bottoming for PIV," etc.)
I will not be giving participants in violation of this rule the option to leave the DNW up without enforcement; participants will be given the choice to edit their sign ups or have them removed from the exchange.
DNWs of "non-canon gender/sexuality headcanons" or "gender/sexuality headcanons" will conflict with many requests (for example, they would conflict with requesting a character in a same sex relationship if that character doesn't explicitly experience same sex attraction in canon) and will only apply to canon characters. As what constitutes a "headcanon" in the context of narrative fanfic (vs. fan discussion or meta) is ambiguous, I recommend you use something else more specific. If you don't want the characters to discuss their sexual orientations or gender identities explicitly, DNW that.
3. Regarding DNWs on the subject of characters' ethnic backgrounds: Similarly to above, you may DNW racebending or changing a character's ethnic background, race, or skin tone/physical description, but you may not DNW people of a given ethnicity or race in a story. Some characters, particularly existing within franchises, may have multiple backstories which give different ethnic backgrounds or appearances. It's fine to DNW a specific version's backstory; it is not fine to do so with offensive language. As above, if you violate this rule, I will require you to edit your sign up or have it removed from the exchange.
4. While I generally give people something of the benefit of the doubt, if I have evidence to believe you are likely to behave unreasonably, for example, your recent public behavior in other exchanges, I may ban you on this basis on my sole discretion. (If you're worrying this is about you, and you have not recently done something which would violate point one on this list, it probably isn't.)
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
Basically, I know some people DNW that because they don't want anachronistic terminology, or coming out scenes, or the characters applying a label to their sexuality/gender, or transgender AUs, and any of those are fine, but you need to be clear and specific.
no subject
no subject
(frozen) no subject
Does this mean you can DNW specific OCs being trans (or another identity)? Would it be permissible to request OW and DNW the main characters in the fic being trans, for example?
(frozen) no subject
(frozen) no subject
(frozen) no subject
(frozen) no subject
I think this is a probably well-intentioned rule that you made in the interests of inclusivity, but the actual effect is the opposite because you're making it too risky for trans nonnies who would get triggered by a bad (or sometimes not even bad just too personal) portrayal of trans characters to participate. You appear to assume that people use DNWs as a value judgement and that the only reason we DNW trans characters is because of bigotry, which is a very uncomfortable and frankly ignorant way to approach DNWs.
I'm not going to continue arguing about this (I was not the initial anon, just the one who asked about baking in gender identity into the OW tags) - it's your exchange and you set the rules. The exchange definitely isn't for me, but not because I "can't stand the very small chance that someone, unprompted, might write any sort of story about a trans character as your gift" but because I think paying lip-service to inclusivity but disregarding the negative effects this has on the vulnerable group(s) you seem to want to protect creates an environment where I don't want to participate in a fannish activity.
(frozen) no subject
The vast majority of discussion of trans issues comes in the form of DNWs, and discussion of those DNWs; actual fic about trans people in exchanges is pretty rare. I have often been upset by those DNWs, and discussion of why people use those DNWs. I am not the only one, judging by both messages I've received over the past few years, and the arguments that play out anonymously, although people are reluctant to discuss the issue in namespace. I found I was increasingly dreading running events, and reluctant to sign up, because of the feeling of a hostile environment I had. So I decided to change my enforcement policies and stop giving exceptions, and I found I felt better about running exchanges.
Dysphoria can make you think and feel really nasty things about both yourself, and other people. I've been there and it sucks. Having those feelings is not your fault. It's still unacceptable to express them directly to those people, or in public, open spaces. Somebody who can't stand narrative fiction about trans people with different POVs from them and needs events to take that into account in the rules is a step past that and is not, in my opinion, in a place where they should be participating in public gift exchanges of fiction at all.
As we are well past any pretense of seeking clarification, I am freezing this thread.